Before investing in automation, the unavoidable question is: how much will I get back, and how fast?
At JANCUBE we use a three-step method to calculate the ROI of any automation process, without relying on optimistic projections or vague estimates.
Step 1: Measure the current cost of the process
The first step is to understand how much the process you want to automate costs you today. That includes:
- Hours of human work per run of the process
- Frequency of execution (daily, weekly, monthly)
- Cost of errors: rework, corrections, impact on other teams
- Opportunity cost: what that team could be doing if it weren't doing this
A company of 500 people with an HR process that occupies 3 people for 8 hours a week, at an average hourly cost of CLP 25,000, spends CLP 600,000 per week on that process. Per year: CLP 31.2 million.
Step 2: Estimate the post-automation cost
Once automated, the process needs no manual intervention in 80-90% of cases. The remaining cost is:
- Periodic supervision (1-2 hours per week)
- Maintenance of the solution (included in the support contract)
- Exceptional cases that require human intervention
In the same example: from 24 hours a week to 2 hours. Savings: 92% of the operating cost.
Step 3: Calculate the payback period
With the numbers in hand, the formula is simple:
Payback period = Investment / Monthly savings
If the automation costs CLP 12 million and the monthly savings are CLP 2.6 million, the payback period is 4.6 months.
From the fifth month on, the solution generates a net return.
What people forget to calculate
Beyond the hours saved, there are impacts that get underestimated:
- Fewer errors: a data entry error can cost 10x more than the original work
- Response speed: processes that took days now take minutes
- Scalability: the automated process handles double the volume at no additional cost
- Team satisfaction: fewer tedious tasks = less turnover
When does automating NOT make sense?
Not every process has a positive ROI in the short term. Avoid automating:
- Processes that change constantly (every week)
- Processes with very low frequency (less than once a month)
- Processes where human judgment is irreplaceable at every step
The key is to first identify where the volume is and where the pain is.